|
Review by: Daniel
Date:4/30/03
Provided by: MSI |
MSI K7N2G nForce
2 Motherboard Review
MSI is well known for making motherboards that
are high in quality. Today we take a look at the MSI K7N2G-ILSR, which is a
motherboard that features the nVIDIA nForce 2 IGP and MCP-T
Chipsets. The nForce 2 in general supports DualDDR and DDR400, and
AGP8x which is a big leap from the original nForce SPP. This
chipset is also the fastest currently for the AMD K7 platform. It
features Hyper-Transport technology that was developed by AMD for
their own chipsets. Hyper-Transport allows the data that is
transferred to and from the northbridge and southbridge even faster
and efficient than VIA's 533mb/s V-Link Solution in the VIA KT333
and KT400
chipsets. Let’s have a look at the K7N2G-ILSR now.

On
the back of the box, we see that this board has a lot of features.
Starting from the top, it features AGP8x, Serial ATA, 5.1 Channel nVidia
Soundstorm integrated sound, IEEE1394 Firewire port, the MSI D-Bracket 2
with LED's for troubleshooting, Fuzzy Logic 4 which features software
overclocking from within Windows, Live Update 2 is software that updates
drivers and bios from the internet, and finally PC Alert 4 which is
basically a software temperature and voltage monitor for Windows. These
are a lot of features that come with this motherboard, and add to the
value of it. Notice that I mentioned that the board features nVidia
Soundstorm 5.1 channel sound. This motherboard is one of few nForce 2
motherboards that have the Soundstorm built-in. It also carries the
Dolby-Digital logo, which means it's Dolby certified. This is good for
users and system integrators who want to have 5.1 Dolby-Digital sound
out of the box.

 
Included inside the box are the manual, driver CD, a promise driver
disk, the manual, and some bonus software. They also give you two
SerialATA cables, 2 IDE ribbon cables and an I/O plate for the back of
the case. I wish MSI would give its customers an IDE to SerialATA
adapter for people who do not have SerialATA hard drives yet, so they
can at least get a taste of SerialATA technology. Abit has been known
to bundle one adapter with some of their motherboards for the same price
as the K7N2G. A domed MSI sticker is also included to put on the
front of your case.

This bracket features both a powered Firewire IEEE1394 port, and an
non-powered Firewire port.

This
bracket that comes with the motherboard is what makes it Dolby
Certified. This bracket has the optical sound out, composite sound out,
rear speakers out, and finally the subwoofer channel-out.

This is MSI's D-Bracket, which features four
diagnostic LED's, which make up combinations to tell the user what is
wrong with the computer. For example, all 4 lights are green,
which means that the system is working properly. The LED's will
turn red if there is something wrong with the motherboard, from bios
failures to memory controller problems. MSI states that this
D-Bracket is helpful for overclockers, because it tells them if the
memory is clocked too high or the CPU is clocked too high, or not enough
voltage. There is also a USB 2.0 port next to the LED's, there are
5 total USB 2.0 ports on this motherboard.

The K7N2G-ILSR features the nForce 2 IGP, which
means it has an Integrated Graphics Processor. The graphics processor is
the NV17 based GeForce 4 MX. It doesn't tell you which GeForce 4
MX series it is, but from the benchmarks conducted, it is rather close
to a GeForce 4 MX 440. Since this motherboard has integrated
video, MSI includes a bracket which has Composite TV-out, and
S-Video Out.


This is the MSI K7N2G-ILSR itself. You can see that the color
scheme is really nice. From the red motherboard PCB to the
purple and green memory slots. This motherboard will really look
good in a case with a window modification. Lets go over the different
components and slots on the motherboard. There is a socket 462
for an AMD Duron, Athlon, or Athlon XP. The nForce 2 supports
the 333mhz FSB, and it has theoretical support for 400mhz FSB bartons. There
are 5 PCI slots, and one blue ACR slot.
The
yellow IDE ports allow for up to 5 IDE devices, the third IDE port
only supports one IDE device to allow the 2 SATA
ports to work.

Under the sleek looking northbridge fan, there is
the nForce 2 IGP, which features an intergrated GeForce 4 MX that is
rated at MX ~440 speeds when using an Athlon 2100+ or greater, with at
least 256mb of ram.
The speeds of the IGP really depend on the memory speed along with
processor speed. The red slot is for the AGP video card.
It supports AGP8x.

3 memory
slots (purple and green slots) allow for DualDDR. To utilize
DualDDR, you need to have one stick of memory in the green slot, and
either one or two of the purple memory slots need to be populated.
nVIDIA states that you need two sticks of DDR400 to utilize the full
power of DualDDR.

Also
this motherboard requires the standard ATX power connector along with
the P4 power connector. Having two power connectors allows maximum CPU and Memory stability.

The heatsinks placed on top of the MOSFET amplifiers,
should allow greater stability and overclockability.

On the
back of the motherboard, there are two PS/2 connectors for the
keyboard and mouse, Four USB2.0 ports, one serial port, one parallel
port, the VGA out port, one 10/100 Ethernet port, and jacks for audio
out, audio in, and microphone.

This is the nForce 2 MCP-T, it is a southbridge responsible for
IDE, Audio, and the 10/100 Ethernet

The
Promise PDC20376 chip is responsible for one ATA/133 port, allowing up to
133mb/s to be transfered. It also controls both SerialATA ports. The SerialATA
ports allow up to 150mb/s transfer rate, and the use of the SerialATA
cable, which should make your case neater. SerialATA Drives are
beginning to show up on the market now, and they should become the
standard within a couple of years.


Here is
a picture of the SerialATA connector, and the picture of the cable
plugged in. Notice how much smaller it is compared to the IDE
ports. Also in the second picture it shows the red wire that the
SerialATA uses, even smaller than a rounded IDE cable and more
flexible.

This is
the K7N2G next to the fairly new Gigabyte GA-7VAXP. Notice both
have stunning color PCB and nice layout. One problem that I found in
the MSI K7N2G's IDE ports is that they are facing horizontally, while
the GA-7VAXP IDE ports are facing vertical. I find it easier to
plug in the IDE cables when they are vertical, because if you have a
mid-size or bigger case, the drives will tend to be higher, requiring
a longer cable. This problem is very minor, and should not be
considered to be bad enough not to consider buying this board.

This is
the main page of the BIOS. The MSI K7N2G utilizes the AwardBIOS,
which is found in almost every motherboard. Lets have a look at the
BIOS.

This is
the part of the BIOS where user would commonly change the boot device
priority, and change other boot options. Notice that you can
turn the full screen logo during the start up of the BIOS on and off.
This is convenient if you want to see the boot up procedure, like the
clock speed, and the memory speed.

This is
the integrated peripherals page. This controls most of the
features located in the nForce 2 MCP-T. Under the Onboard Super
I/O device menu, there is a simple Enable/Disable option to turn on
and off the floppy drive controller.

Under
the IDE Function Setup page, you can control the IDE channels, and the
modes that you want each channel to work at. A minor issue that
I have found is that there is no option to turn off the onboard RAID
chip (Promise SATA controller.) So, even though you don't need
the chip, the motherboard will still initialize the chip and load the
chips BIOS. Again, this is a very minor issue.

This is
the Onboard Device menu, which controls almost all the features of the
nForce 2 multimedia controller. You can enable and disable the
AC97 SoundStorm Audio, the Onboard USB (selecting between USB1.1 and
2.0), the firewire, and the LAN. You can also enter your own MAC
Address for the 10/100 LAN and the Firewire port.

These
are the advanced chipset features. This is one of the menus for
overclocking and tweaking your computer. Here you can control
your CPU FSB from 100 to 200mhz. MSI also included a CPU
interface control, which basically lets the motherboard load the
overclocked CPU parameters, so if you select a 133mhz FSB, you will
get a FSB of 135.50mhz when the overclocked parameters are used.
With the memory, you can select the FSB/DRAM ratio which divides the
FSB and the memory FSB, for example, a 1:1 ratio will let you have the
CPU FSB and RAM speeds equal (ex. 133/133) a 1:2 ratio will double the
rams speeds, (133/166). Under the memory options, you can adjust
the timings for the ram. Also in the menu are the AGP 8x Support
enable and disable switch, the fast writes enable and disable, and the
AGP Aperture Size control.

In the
Frequency and Voltage Control menu, you can change the AGP clock and
AGP Voltage, which is helpful for overclocking the video card.
There is the DRAM voltage adjust for the ram, which lets you adjust
the ram voltage from 2.5Volts to 2.7Volts, which seems too little,
since other motherboards lets you go to 2.8Volts. For the CPU,
you can change the multiplier from 7.0x to 13.0x, the VCore can also
be changed from 1.500 Volts, to 1.850 Volts. The last option which is
PCI Clock Auto Detect, allows you to Enable and Disable the PCI Clock
Lock, which is very helpful when overclocking, since it keeps the PCI
clock at 33mhz.

This is
the PC Health Status screen. Which shows the user the system
temperature, cpu temperature, fan speed and voltages. You can
enable and disable the warning beep for the cpu temperatures, and the
threshold for the temperature beep. Notice that there is no
option to adjust what temperature to turn off the CPU. The
manual states that it will turn off automatically when the temps reach
110 C, which is way too high for a CPU anyways. People have also
complained about the CPU and System temperatures being too high with
the 1.2 bios revision, and too low with the 1.3 revision. Notice
that the bios above is the 1.3 version, which displays the CPU
temperature anywhere from 98F to 107F, which is a bit low, it can
range +/- 15 F from the actual temperature of the CPU core. The
system (case temperature) is also affected by this problem, either
being too low or too high.
MSI K7N2G-ILSR Review
The MSI K7N2G-ILSR test system that we will be using consists of an:
-
AMD Athlon XP Thoroughbred 1700+ @ 2600+(2.04ghz)(12*170)
-
MSI K7N2G-ILSR nForce 2
Motherboard
-
1 stick of 256 MB of Crucial PC2700 Memory
-
60GB Maxtor UltraDMA/133 Hard Drive
-
MSI nVIDIA GeForce 4 Ti4200
Graphics Card
-
Cooler Master ATC-111 case for temperatures
The Soltek SL-75FRN-L
-
AMD Athlon XP Thoroughbred 1700+ @ 2600+
-
256 MB DDR 333
-
Soltek 75FRN-L nforce2 MCP (not T version)
-
Geforce3 Ti (200/460 @ 240/560) core/memory
-
WD 40 Gb 7000rpm HDD
-
Coolermaster ATC-220 case

When the MSI K7N2G is compared to the Soltek SL-75FRN-L, MSI's CPU
score is always going to be a little bit higher, due to the default
FSB of 135.50mhz when the High Performance bios settings are
activated. There is really no difference between the two
motherboards in the CPU benchmark.

In the memory benchmarks however, the MSI is 2 mb/s slower than the
Soltek motherboard. Again, this is a very minimal difference.

The MSI K7N2G scores well over the Gigabyte GA-7VAXP in 3Dmark2001SE,
which is based on the VIA KT400. It appears that the MSI
motherboard gives
nVIDIA graphics cards a boost of about 800 more 3Dmarks. The Soltek test bed had the GeForce 3 video card, and scores well for a
GeForce 3.

These are the 3DMark2001SE results comparing the nVIDIA nForce 2 IGP
against the MSI GeForce 4 Ti 4200. As you can see the IGP scores
much lower than the GeForce 4 Ti 4200. nVidia states that the
IGP is a GeForce 4 MX, which means that the graphics core is the same
as the GeForce 2 (a DirectX7 generation card). Adding more RAM
would increase the performance slightly due to the fact that the
nForce 2 ICP uses a shared memory architecture. I would say that
the performance of the IGP is equal to a GeForce 4 MX 440, which is
great improvement from the original nForce IGP.
Over-Clocking
Both motherboards overclock very well, reaching 2.16ghz (180x12) which
is equal to about a 2600+ on the AMD scale with the same PC2700 memory
module. However, there were some instability issues with the MSI
motherboard. If you overclock too high, the bios will not boot
until two reset jumpers on the motherboard are reset. This can
be a hassle for overclockers trying to figure out the maximum
stability of their CPU and RAM. Other motherboard brands don't
come with the jumpers and their owners are forced to either put in a
100mhz FSB CPU in the socket or RMA the motherboard back to where they
bought it from. MSI has done a great job ensuring the jumpers
are there for resetting the bios.
Overall, this motherboard provides the performance that the nForce 2
IGP chipset was designed for. At a retail price of around 130
dollars, this motherboard is not the cheapest nForce 2 based
motherboard. MSI is not ripping you off with the expensive price
tag though, you get everything you need in one box. With
on-Board Video, Sound, 10/100 LAN, Firewire, USB2.0 and SerialATA, you
wouldn't need to buy other system components if you are a first time
computer builder, computer retailer or you just want to save money.
All the cables are included too, for the Floppy, IDE Drives and the
SerialATA ports. The K7N2G with all these features, and its moderate
overclocking abilities, this motherboard is a great value.
Techaddicts Computer Reviews would like to give the MSI K7N2G-ILSR a
rating of 8.5 out of 10 stars!
Home
©Techaddicts.net Networks, All rights reserved.
|